Book Review: A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas

"We need hope, or else we cannot endure." – Sarah J. Maas

If you love fantasy, romance, and a touch of danger, A Court of Thorns and Roses (ACOTAR) might just be your next obsession. This New York Times bestselling novel is a loose Beauty and the Beast retelling, but don’t expect the usual fairy tale—it’s darker, steamier, and filled with twists that will keep you turning the pages.

Plot Overview (No Spoilers!)

Feyre Archeron is a mortal huntress struggling to feed her family in a world divided between humans and fae. When she kills a wolf in the woods, she unknowingly disrupts an ancient treaty and is taken beyond the wall into the magical lands of Prythian. There, she becomes entangled in the mysteries of the Spring Court and its High Lord, Tamlin. But the more she learns about the faerie realm, the more she realizes that something dark is lurking, and her fate is tied to it in ways she never imagined.

What Makes This Book Stand Out

The World-Building – Maas creates a richly detailed world with powerful courts, ancient magic, and deep lore. The descriptions make it easy to get lost in Prythian.

The Slow-Burn Tension – The first half of the book lays the groundwork for the romance and conflict, but once the story picks up, it becomes impossible to put down. The last third is filled with action, drama, and twists.

The Characters & Their Secrets – If you enjoy morally complex characters and unexpected twists, this book delivers. The way the series evolves in later books changes everything you thought you knew.

Why ACOTAR is a Great Book Club Pick

If your book club enjoys stories that inspire deep discussions, ACOTAR is a fantastic choice.

Plenty to Discuss – Themes of power, survival, and romance create engaging conversations. Is Tamlin a hero or villain? Should Feyre have made different choices?

A Mix of Fantasy and Romance – The book appeals to both fantasy and romance lovers, making it a well-rounded pick for a diverse group.

A Gateway to a Series – If your club enjoys ongoing discussions, ACOTAR sets the stage for an even more dramatic and expansive story in the later books.

Strong Reader Reactions – Some readers love it, others find it overhyped, but either way, it sparks opinions. A book that divides readers often makes for the best discussions.

Things to Know Before Reading

• Slow Start – The first few chapters focus on world-building, but the payoff is worth it.
• Romance & Spice – This book is mostly YA-friendly, but the series becomes more mature as it progresses.
• The Real Action Begins Later – The first book sets up the world, but later books shift in tone, introducing new characters and higher stakes.

Final Thoughts: Is ACOTAR Worth the Read?

This book has become a favorite for fantasy romance fans, and for good reason. If you enjoy lush world-building, slow-burn romance, and a heroine who grows into her power, ACOTAR is worth the read. Some find it overhyped, but if you stick with it, you might just fall in love with Prythian and its characters.

Rating: 4/5 Stars

Let’s Discuss on Instagram

Have you read A Court of Thorns and Roses? Overhyped or worth the hype? Join the conversation on Instagram @thebibliophile_boutique.

Looking for your next book club pick? Follow @thebibliophile_boutique for book recommendations, reviews, and exclusive bookish finds.